Tropical astrology (the original astrology you guys are using) in my opinion, is really inaccurate. Why? Because I'm a Leo sun and an Aries moon but I'm not out-going at all, nor am I extroverted.
There was a girl who was a Pisces sun, Pisces moon, and Pisces rising but she talks A LOT, and I mean A LOT! She's not shy being in front of the stage at all and she's extremely out-going! She's not shy or sensitive at all (as her signs suggested). She's also acts really weird and sarcastic at times.
Why is Tropical astrolgy so inaccurate? Well, because there's something called 'Vedic astrology'. In Vedic astrolgy I'm a Cancer sun and Pisces moon and I'm shy and sensitive. I also got my Sun and Mercury both in 12th house which makes me introverted and quiet. I never knew my Vedic chart until I looked it up just yesterday.
The Pisces girl that I mentioned just a while ago is, in fact, an Aquarius in Vedic astrology, including her moon and rising sign. That explains her quirkiness and weird behavior.
Okay, so I admit I can be pretty impulsive at times and such, but that's because I have Mars conjunct my ascendant (in both Tropical and Vedic astrology) which makes me have traits of an Aries.
In Tropical astrology I got Jupiter in 1st house which is supposed to make you extremely large in size and have big bone structure, but surprisingly I am really fragile and have such small bone structure and a small face! Why? Because technically, my Jupiter is in the 2nd house in my Vedic chart!
See? My Vedic chart resonates with me A LOT more including several other people. This is, however, my personal opinion. I don't care what you say about Vedic astrology, because this astrology is definitely the more accurate one!
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
Wow Dude !!! I think Tropical is accurate just like sidereal. It depends on the reader. I can read a book and mispronounce word and another can read the same lines correctly. The written meaning stays the same even though it sounds different to our ears by the speaker LOL
WTF...td for what ? didn't say anything wrong did I ?
post your tropical and vedic charts and ill try to explain this
unless the vedic chart youre using uses equal or whole sign houses, the houses should be the same. i.e., if your sun and mercury are in the 12th in vedic they should be in tropical.. and this would more than explain the shyness which is your flagship reason for why you think tropical is inaccurate..
as for the jupiter thing, youre neglecting two facts. 1. youre neglecting your actual rising sign and its ruler and any aspects to it and just taking the interpretation of jupiter in first. 2. not everything in a chart is going to fit for a person, considering there are contradictory things all over anyones chart (imagine someone with gemini sun but pisces moon - how can they be talkative and extroverted but shy and withdrawn? get what i mean?) - you might have something else explaining your physical description
and even more, the physical description stuff in astrology seems to be the most hit and miss out of everything. some people are like exact physical manifestations of how the signs are supposed to look, some people dont look like the physical stuff will at all.
i cant be bothered to figure this out or not but do you have virgo rising perhaps? based on what you said i suspect you might. and if that is the case.. smallness of physical features is a virgo trait...