Verified answer

That's a very balanced trade. No one really gains from it. Hamels can be both good and bad but Derek Lee will not dissapoint.

It is not a fair trade. Think about it Guerrero is doing alot in a weak batting order, while Gaudin looks alot like Jared Weaver of last year. Okay, look at it this way are Guerrero and Gaudin more consistent or are Hamels and Lee?

It seems pretty straight laced if you ask me. However, before you get Derrek Lee, look at who he plays for! The Cubs are playing really poorly right now. He seems to be in a slump. I'm sure he'll come around. Vlad is a constant helper in a fantasy league.

It's totally up to you. Personally, I'd take the trade in hopes that Lee turns his season back into the season he was having in spring training. You'll get the better end of the deal once he comes around. Good luck in the league.

although vlad is great, Lee and hamels is too good of a offer to spoil. Hamels could get 230 strikeouts and Lee is gonna pick up where he left off 2 yrs. ago

i dont really think so. vlad will give you huge numbers in AVG, RBI, and HRs,tho his K's are high he is better than lee. Gaudin and hamels are pretty much equal

Whaaatt?

I would not do the trade