Verified answer

Vogelsong? Really? Last season was something of an anomaly for a pitcher who hadn't appeared in the big leagues in five years and I'd be shocked if he catches lightning in a bottle again. And Hardy hasn't been immune to the injury bug, either, averaging just 115 games over the last three seasons.

You should be able to get a solid starting pitcher and a decent shortstop in exchange for Reyes. Don't settle for a couple scrubs in a deal that will almost undoubtely be vetoed (unless you're offering it to the league commissioner).

um.... NO. There are definitely good free agent options to pick up without having to drop someone like Reyes.