Verified answer

I would probably take Team 2. Prince Fielder has been cool, but he's definetely a power threat. Soriano can get you steals and homeruns, and Griffey can hit homers. There's always the potential that Griffey can get injured.

Lee will give you a good batting average, Ramirez is heating up and will give you homeruns and a pretty good average, and Ichiro will give you a great average and steals. Plus, Roy Halladay is a great starter. Team 2 ends up getting more steals, and a much higher average, and pitching. All three players on Team 2 have averages over .300, where only one does on Team 1.

Lets break this down.

Fielder > Lee ---- Advantage team 1

Manny = Soriano ----- Tie

Ichiro > Griffey ----- Advantage team 2

Roy Hallday for free ---Advantage team 2

Basically, you are getting an upgrade at OF, while a downgrade at 1B. Then, team 2 gets Halladay (who is having a bad year by his standards, but is still a very good pitcher). So if you are getting a free ace pitcher, then make the deal.

Team 2 wins

I would say Team 2.

Prince vs. Lee - Potentially even. Lee is more proven veteran though.

Soriano and Griffey vs. Ichiro and Ramirez - Also somewhat even. Nice mix of HRs and SBs and RBIs.

Team 2 gets Halladay which is why they win. Everybody else is pretty even.

I think that this trade is pretty close to even. I would say Team 1 would be better if you need Power - if you need speed, runs scored, average and pitching help - I would say Team 2.

Team 2 by far. More players and more talent.

team 2 no doubt