Verified answer

I'd almost do this. In a 14 team league, Johnson and Portis are outstanding starting RBs! As PZ states, this injury thing with Portis is an internet soundbyte not supported by facts. His mini meltdown at the end of the season was more a function of the total collapse of the Skins offense than him being injured - hell, he was in on pass protection half the time. So you're getting 2 high ranked RBs in exchange for one.

If possible, I'd try to do this without getting rid of Boldin. What if you gave up Turner, White, Lynch and Jenkins for Portis, Johnson and Cotchery? You're weak at #2 WR, but you'd retain Boldin, and I think TO is a huge downgrade from Boldin. People forget that Boldin missed 4 games last season and came back too soon from injury. He was walking away with the WR stats before this happened! Way in 1st place. I'd try to find a way to keep him, because that trade as I listed it would benefit someone weak at RB.

I would not do this trade, Boldin is a beast and a top 5 receiver, Turner is a top 3 receiver, White should get a good bulk of the TD's in Tenn. M. Lynch should be more productive than last year after his suspension because opponents will have to focus on the pass w/ TO and L. Evans.

TO is still really good, but who knows if he'll fit in on this team, could be more drama, C. Johnson is awesome but not as good as Turner, and will lose a lot of TD's to L. White, Portis is still a beast but getting old, and prone to injuries. Cotchery should be a number 1 this year for NY but he'll only be as good as his QB?. D. Rhodes should not be on anyone's roster until someone gets hurt. .

I wouldnt accept the trade. Michael turner = #2 running backk. thaqt would just be foolish. and marshawn lynch suspended first 3 games and is backed up by some solid running backs so he probably will end up splitting carries. also jerrio doesnt have brett favre any more. portis is most likely gonna get injured too. your lendale white always punches the ball in at the goal line to get the touch down points and chris johnson gets the yards so its pretty much a wash between them two. i personally wouldnt accept this trade. but its your team do what u wish. good luck with what ever you decide

no do not trade boldin is a top 10 wr turner is top 5 rb white is the goal line back so bad for chris johnson lynch is good after is 3 game suspension owens is getting washed up cotchery is no better than a number 2 wr chris johnson is not getting goal line tds clinton protis is good but gets injured alot

Bad trade man. You shouldnt give up Turner. I just hope you have another good RB. Chris Johnson is good, but Turner was wayyyy better.

i would suggest offering a counter trade

Maybe bruce and lynch for cotchery and portis. Its a stretch but definitely better then that huge and unfair trade you were offered.

This whole "Clinton Portis gets injured a lot" thing... what is this based off of?

He's played 16 games in back to back seasons...

I wouldn't do it if I were you. Boldin, Turner, White, and Lynch are all good players, esp Boldin and Turner.

While you would be getting some good players, the players you currently have are going to be more productive players.

Don't do that trade.

I would love to tell you, you got the better end of the deal, which I "think" you did, but really it all depends on what your scoring format is.