who wins this trade? Nonppr. 6keeper league. Roster size is 1qb 2rb 3wr 1wr/te 1wr/rb 1wr/te/rb 1te 1k 1def.
Team A obvious keepers
jordy nelson, jennings, percy
lynch, jonathan stewart
Team B
randall cobb,
steven jackson, chris johnson, darren sproles
TRADE
percy and jordy for cobb and jackson
Update:lavadog.. ur an idiot. it has a huge roster in a 6 keeper league! there are NO runningbacks in the draft in a 12 team league. even in a 10 team it still is a stupid arguement to not keep stewart. i have fred jackson, and pierre thomas but neither of them have the upside of stewart. i'd rather keep the possibility. team b has only 1 decent wr in cobb. outside of cobb he's looking at manningham, burress, meachem, moss and hilton (the only other option). we can start up to 6 wrs or up to 4 rbs. right now with team A their first pick will be ball as he is the best option. but bell and all other rookies and vareen and ingram and andre brown will be gone by the time it comes back. its a 4th year keeper.. good players are taken... i inherited for a guy that got kicked out and was the worse team...obviously. a 2nd round rb for me, best case, would be micheal bush or leshoure.. neither are worth more than stewart IMO unless injury. i need to trade my wr's for rbs and then get lucky
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
Cobb and Jackson is a lot better. Harvin is good but always gets hurt. Jordy and Cobb both gain value now that Jennings is gone but Cobb will have a little more value since he gets carries. Jackson is also a top 15 RB this year and should do really well in ATL.
First of all.. there is no way Team A should keep Jonathan Stewart. PERIOD. There are many rookie RBs who will see playing time that you can grab in the draft since none of them could possibly have been a keeper yet. (L. Bell PIT RB, M. Ball DEN RB, E. Lacy GB RB, G. Bernard CIN RB) There is no need to waste a keeper selection on a RB you can't rely on.. use it on a more consistently productive player. Not to mention guys like Mendenhall AZ RB and Chris Ivory NJY RB are probably unowned.
Use it on a QB, TE.. whatever, there's got to be something else you can salvage from last season's roster.
Cobb and Jordy are a wash, because Rodgers spreads the ball around.. so they're both equally likely to break out this season. The trade is basically Percy for SJax.. while SJax's ADP is higher than Percy's, can you say he is greater fantasy football contributor? If the answer is Yes, then pull the trigger. If the answer is no, take your ball and go home.
cobb jackson better..... GO PACK GO