Tigers get: Matt Holliday, Adam Wainwright, Shelby Miller, Zach Cox, Allen Craig

Cardinals get: Justin Verlander, Rick Porcello, Austin Jackson, Victor Martinez(when healthy)

If you were a GM would you pull the trigger on that trade? If so who do you think would get the better end of the trade. Its just hypothetical and i am just wondering what other people think, personally i think the Tigers would get the much better end of the trade.

@lightning you cant compare Porcello to Cox because Cox is a third baseman, nor can you compare Miller and Holliday to Martinez, Holliday yes, but Miller is a pitcher in my opinion Miller is better than Porcello and Holliday is better than Martinez. Up until last season Wainwright was better than Verlander, or at the very least damn close to same level, if you guy kept Porcello it would be a fair trade

Ok new proposal then

Tigers get: LF Matt Holliday, SP Shelby Miller, 1B Matt Adams, 3B Zach Cox

Cardinals get: 1B/C Victor Martinez, SP Rick Porcello, CF Austin Jackson

What do you think about that trade instead, if you like the first better tell me why