Alright so I have proposed this trade to this guy, but he has declined. I need to know if I am just lowballing him or if he's being stupid. I think its a fair deal. What do you think I should propose instead?
I give:
Greg Jennings
Brandon Lloyd
I get:
MJD
10 teams, no ppr
My team:
My Team
QB: Dalton
RB: Foster
RB: Charles
WR: Demaryous Thomas
WR: Julio Jones
TE: Davis
RB/WR: Redman
DST: Giants
K: Walsh
BN: Greg Jennings
BN: Britt
BN: Colston
BN: Brandon Lloyd
BN: Rivers
BN: Felix Jones
BN: Romo
His Team
QB: Peyton Manning
RB: Ridely
RB: Lynch
WR: Mike Wallace
WR: Miles Austin
TE: Daniels
RB/WR: Mathews
DST: Falcons
K: Henery
BN: MJD
BN: James Casey (hou te)
BN: Crabtree
BN: Meachem
BN: Spiller
BN: Schaub
BN: Sydney Rice
What do you guys think? He needs the WR help. And he knows it.
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
It's not a terrible offer especially with MJD's status up in the air, but Jennings has been injured all year and may not do much if and when he comes back since this is the end of his contract and the other receivers are all performing well. Lloyd is up and down, but has done a bit more lately. Both have potential, but present risks. At best, he'd be upgrading his bench. Just because something is fair doesn't mean the other owner necessarily has to make a trade or make him stupid. I generally don't accept 2 for 1 trades either - you have to drop another player to accept the deal.
If you really want MJD, try offering Colston for him. that's a deal I would take if I were the other guy.