Verified answer

Matthews has beastmode upside;Where as Smith has commode upside..

That's a great trade;Sure they are both injury prone,but Matthews has top 4 RB talent when healthy right behind the big 3 RBs.

GL

All day, and this is coming from a HUGE Lions fan. Smith is very injury prone, and will not even be the #1 option once Leshoure comes back from suspension.

I would not make that trade especially with Mathews being hurt. I would keep Smith.

Take it. Matthews is just as injury prone as Smith but he is the featured back whereas Smith is in the starting role while others are hurt or suspended

Please answer mine:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AkEPE...