Without giving detail about whose team is whose.
Team 1:
QB Cam Newton, Car QB
RB Adrian Peterson, Min RB
RB Chris Johnson, Ten RB
WR A.J. Green, Cin WR
WR Vincent Jackson, TB WR
TE Greg Olsen, Car TE
FLEX Shane Vereen, NE RB
D/ST 49ers D/ST D/ST
K Justin Tucker, Bal K
Bench Rashard Mendenhall, Ari RB
Bench Ben Roethlisberger, Pit QB
Bench Steve Johnson, Buf WR
Bench Chris Ivory, NYJ RB
Bench Dwayne Allen, Ind TE
Bench Denarius Moore, Oak WR
Bench Malcom Floyd, SD WR
Team 2
QB Drew Brees, NO QB
RB Jamaal Charles, KC RB
RB Vick Ballard, Ind RB
WR Brandon Marshall, Chi WR
WR Reggie Wayne, Ind WR
TE Tony Gonzalez, Atl TE
FLEX Danny Amendola, NE WR
D/ST Texans D/ST D/ST
K Blair Walsh, Min K
Bench DeAngelo Williams, Car RB
Bench Matthew Stafford, Det QB
Bench Pierre Garcon, Wsh WR
Bench Brandon Myers, NYG TE
Bench Ryan Broyles, Det WR
Bench Josh Gordon, Cle WR
Bench Rueben Randle, NYG WR
The potential trade is:
Team 1 gives Cam Newton, Adrian Peterson, and Reshard Mendenhall.
Team 2 gives Drew Brees, Jamaal Charles, and Danny Amendola
Is this a fair trade? Who comes out on top?
Additional Info: 10 team league, This trade would not go down until next week.
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
i as well dont like to disagree, however: cam newton scored more than 15 points in 10 of his games last season. brees is great, but cam can put up similiar numbers in multiple weeks. ap and charles are both great players however ap will do way more damage. if mendenhall is also given up, someone is going to be short on rbs in bye weeks. i think the player with cam and ap shouldnt do this trade at all.
Hmm... That's a tough trade. But I think team 1 would get the better part of the trade. Drew Brees is going to do even better than last year. Even though Peterson is the best RB, Jamaal Charles is in the top 5. And Danny Amendola is the new Wes Welker. He's going to be Brady's main wide receiver, and he's going to rack up lots of points. It would be good either way, but Team 1 would have the better trade.
i hate to contradict others answers because it causes more confusion- but i disagree with Leah*. you cant lose AP #1, #2 when Pu$$y a$# Amendola goes down for half of the season you will regret it. if it were PPR i would do it in a heartbeat but if you are standard scoring- don't give up AP. Plus, Cam has a huge upside EVERY week.
I think its a doable trade for both sides. If I had to call it I think I would rather have AP just because he is irreplacable. I think its fair though.