Verified answer

Hell no!! Vick and Williams have way too much upside to let them go for Rhodes a guy who is gonna be sharing duties with Addai, and Warner who has been known to get hurt.

On paper, this is a balanced trade. It comes down to personal choice.

Warner is an injury risk, but he's a mad bomber. Rhodes and DeAngelo Williams are both now officially in a Running Back By Committee.

I personally don't trust Michael Vick. He is equally capable of a 3 INT 120 yard game. I prefer pure passers with good wide receivers. The good news is that Vick has a bunch of road -graders for an offensive line. Look how well Dunn is doing again.

I like DeAngelo Williams a lot. Foster never finishes a season, and I think Williams will be the starter. Rhodes is nothing special, and I think Addai will eventually take over as the starter.

I would lean very slightly toward doing the deal.

I dont think so. Warner is good but Vick has been really good this year. He might fall off. Rhodes is splitting time with Addai and the rookie looks better anyway. Williams is going to start getting more carries. He wont be the main guy but he will be seeing more play time. Pretty much it comes down to Warner for Vick. Its a toss up either way. Just ask yourself how long will Warner be the starter?

If you are getting Vick and Williams, then yes. Atlanta seems to have finally found a way to use Vick to the best of his abilities and it is paying off big time for them early. Williams may be on the verge of taking the starting job in Carolina as Foster has been health, but ineffective to this point.

My major concern with Warner is his durability. He has not played an entire season since 2002 and is always one big hit away from the IR. Rhodes is another back who is splitting and has been ineffective. If for anything Addai will supplant him at some point in the season.

I say do it. Warner will get hurt and it looks like Addai might take over for Rhodes. Vick will do well, not as good as Warner, but Vick will probably play more games. Williams may start this week for the Panthers. Pull the trigger!

If you are getting Vick & Williams...TAKE THE TRADE! Everyone knows that Warner is going to get hurt this year. Rhodes is not going to do well because INDY will be relying again on passing and Addai will get many carries also.

Vick has looked pretty darn good in 2 games this season and Williams, well, he is a better pickup if you are in a keeper league but with foster, who may get hurt again, he is a decent pickup.

It also depends on who else you have on your team.

No, No and No. Warner is a better fantasy player than Vick and Rhodes is the starter in Indy, and Williams is on the bench!

I play a lot of fantasy football, so I wouldn't make the trade.

Warner looks good this year and I believe Rhodes will be the Colts #1 RB.

Vick is good but Williams won't get many carries.

I would do it if i were getting Vick